Historical Figure: William Penn (and Lord Baltimore's Catholic Maryland)
Objective: Understand William Penn's 'Holy Experiment' in Pennsylvania and Lord Baltimore's Catholic Maryland as early American models of religious toleration.
William Penn (1644-1718) was an English aristocrat who shocked his powerful family by joining the Quakers (the Society of Friends), a peaceable Protestant group that rejected violence, oaths, and social hierarchy, and was harshly persecuted. To repay a debt owed to Penn's father, King Charles II granted Penn a vast American territory in 1681 — Pennsylvania ('Penn's Woods'). Penn called his colony a 'Holy Experiment': a place built on religious freedom for all who believed in God, fair and peaceful dealings with the Lenape (native peoples) for whom he insisted on buying land honestly, and self-government under a written 'Frame of Government.' Philadelphia, the 'City of Brotherly Love,' became one of the most diverse and successful colonial cities. Penn's experiment ran parallel to an earlier Catholic one: Maryland, founded in 1634 by the Calverts (Lord Baltimore) as a refuge for England's persecuted Catholics. Maryland's 1649 Toleration Act was one of the first laws in the colonies guaranteeing freedom of worship to all Christians — a remarkable early step, though it was later overturned when Protestants gained control. Together, Quaker Pennsylvania and Catholic Maryland planted in American soil the radical idea that people of different faiths could live together in peace — a seed that would grow into the religious liberty of the United States.
Resources
Discussion Questions
- 1What made Penn's 'Holy Experiment' so unusual for its time?
- 2How were Quaker Pennsylvania and Catholic Maryland alike in their treatment of religious difference?
- 3Why did early experiments in toleration matter for the later United States?
Write three sentences comparing Penn's Pennsylvania and Lord Baltimore's Maryland: who founded each, for whom, and what toleration meant in each.
Vocabulary
- Quakers
- the Society of Friends, a peaceable Protestant group rejecting violence and oaths
- Holy Experiment
- Penn's name for Pennsylvania, founded on religious freedom and peace
- toleration
- allowing the free practice of different religions
Maryland (1634, Catholic refuge) and Pennsylvania (1681, Quaker 'Holy Experiment') — early American religious toleration.